Mystery Makeup Box New In Package - Choose 5-10-15-20 Mystery Pieces. The photos show a variety of items you could possibly get in your mystery box and even more that aren't in the pictures. Items can vary in color, shade, and brand. Possible brands you can receive are: Maybelline, Believe Beauty, Kiss, LA Colors, Wet n Wild, Ponds, 7th Heaven, Covergirl, and Broadway. Possible items include: eye cream, nail polish, nail stencils, gel nail strips, lash primer, lipliner, brow pomade, lipstick, lip gloss, highlight powder, contour stick, concealer, false lashes, blush, compact mirror, face mask, bronzing powder, brow pencil, multi-stick, eyeshadow, foundation, and brow mascara.